ANONYMOUS PEER REVIEW FORM

Please return this form via email to rdsj@hawaii.edu, or via mail to Megan Conway, Review of 
Disability Studies, Center on Disability Studies, 1776 University Avenue, UA 4-6, Honolulu, HI 
96822. 

REVIEWER ID ____    MANUSCRIPT ID ____       DATE DUE ____ 
 
ADVICE TO THE EDITOR (WILL NOT BE SENT TO THE AUTHOR) 

Evaluation:                                          High               Low 
 
Contribution to existing knowledge  5     4     3     2     1 
 
Organization and Readability            5     4     3     2     1 
 
Soundness of methodology                5     4     3     2     1 
 
Evidence supports conclusion            5     4     3     2     1 
 
Adequacy of literature review           5     4     3     2     1 
  
____ ACCEPT: The manuscript warrants publication as an anonymous peer reviewed article. It 
is a solid contribution to the understanding of disability studies. It is well conceived and 
executed. 
 
____ ACCEPT WITH MINOR REVISIONS: The manuscript should be accepted after minor 
revisions, noted in the comments, are made. It will then be a sound contribution as an 
anonymous peer reviewed article. (The reviewer's comments must be sufficient for the author 
to respond to the reviewer's concerns.) 
 
____ REVISE AND RESUBMIT: The manuscript does not warrant publication in its current 
form, but it will warrant publication as an anonymous peer reviewed article with suggested 
revisions. (The reviewer's comments must be sufficient for the author to respond to the 
reviewer's concerns.) 
 
____ REJECT: The manuscript does not warrant publication as an anonymous peer reviewed 
article. 
 
Additional Comments:

Comments for the Author from Peer Review


Manuscript ID ____      Title:  ______________________________ 
 
                                                  ______________________________ 
 
Comments for the author(s):